One of the Milburn Review’s most important conclusions is that young people themselves are not the problem to be fixed. More than seven in ten young people who are NEET (not in education, employment, or training) want to work and progress. That strongly reflects what we see through EDT’s own evidence and practice. In our research in the North East of England, young people consistently expressed a desire to be in education, employment, or training, yet many had become disengaged through their personal circumstances, experiences of education, access to work, or fragmented local systems.
Preventing this means acting before difficulties become entrenched, creating genuine routes forward, and the system working together around the young person, so that support stays with them for as long as they need it.
Careers support should focus on trust and continuity, not a one-off conversation
Careers support has an important role to play within this new system, including the practitioner techniques that determine its success. A consistent adviser or mentor can do much more than provide information: they can help a young person navigate choices, build confidence, respond when circumstances change, and connect them with other support when they need it. Our recent research into careers provision in schools demonstrates that for young people who are already disengaged or facing multiple barriers, trust and continuity matter. In practitioner interviews, engagement emerged as a central feature of good practice, rather than a separate activity.
The Review places strong emphasis on creating first opportunities for young people. That matters, but our research in the North East found that many young people had already taken steps into education, training, or employment before their pathway broke down at a critical moment. A course failed to run, an apprenticeship was oversubscribed, a job ended, or support fell away before the next step was secured.
We therefore welcome Milburn’s recommendation for a new Youth Opportunity Service (YOS), where each participating young person will receive sustained, consistent support from a personal adviser. Milburn states that ‘[the YOS’s] responsibility [for the young person] should not end when a referral is made or a job, course or placement begins. Where support is needed, the YOS should remain involved until participation is secure.’
For the YOS to be successful, careers advisers will need both the skills to build trusted relationships and the ability to support young people to find another way forward when circumstances change or their pathway breaks down.
Make apprenticeships visible and achievable
The Review identifies apprenticeships as its largest education and skills priority. We agree that apprenticeships need to play a central role in creating stronger routes from education into work. That means creating more opportunities, but also making sure young people know that those opportunities exist and understand how to access them.
Young people and their families need clear, impartial information about apprenticeships alongside academic and other technical routes. They also need practical support to understand applications, navigate recruitment, and make choices that reflect their interests and circumstances.
Through our work, including on the London programmes Apprenticeships, Information, and Meaningful Encounters (AIM) and Apprenticeships Support and Knowledge (ASK), we have seen the value of making apprenticeship routes more visible and connecting young people, schools, families, and employers with the information they need. In ASK’s final year of delivery (2024-25), 100% of parent/carer survey respondents reported that they were more likely to discuss apprenticeships or other vocational routes with their child, would support their child if they chose these routes, and knew where to go to find more information.
There is no single NEET experience
Crucially, the proposed Support Guarantee – which is framed as deliberately distinct from the Opportunity Guarantee – recognises that an opportunity on its own is not always enough. Young people may also need health, employment, functional, or practical support to access and sustain it.
However, as the Review also recognises, the levels of support needed will vary widely from young person to young person. Some may be close to work but facing a practical barrier such as transport, while others may need support around qualifications, confidence, housing, caring responsibilities, mental health, or disability.
Barriers can also begin much earlier, including during education, which the Review is right to acknowledge. In our work, Emotionally Based School Avoidance (EBSA) has emerged as a prevalent cause of young people becoming NEET post-16. We have seen through our Dorset Marvels programme that young people can make positive transitions when they receive personalised and trauma-informed support, their families are regularly engaged, and different parts of the system work together around them. At one school in Blandford Forum, 82% of young people we supported in this way successfully gained and started a post-16 destination.
EDT research has also found that middle-attaining students, who are not considered high achievers nor formally identified as needing targeted support, may be an overlooked group within schools. Interviewees in our school-based careers guidance research suggested that, without deliberate attention, these students may miss out on the right support, despite representing a large proportion of the school population. The Support Guarantee should ensure that young people who fall into this less visible group do not slip through the cracks.
Build on what already works locally
The Review highlights the success of Careers Hubs and existing employer engagement infrastructure, calling for these foundations to be strengthened rather than creating separate initiatives. Our experience delivering West London Careers Hub shows the value of bringing schools and colleges, employers, local authorities, and careers professionals together around young people. In 2025, we worked with 358 employers to create meaningful careers and workplace experiences for young people, with 100% of participating schools reporting a positive impact on their students. Building on these existing local partnerships could help the Youth Opportunity Service connect young people with both the guidance and the opportunities they need.
Employers need support to both create opportunities and help young people access them
The Review is right to look beyond what needs to change for young people and consider the role employers play in making opportunity possible.
Financial incentives can form part of the solution. But our experience also shows that employers can need practical support to give young people meaningful opportunities, particularly smaller organisations or those supporting young people with additional needs.
That can mean brokerage, guidance around safeguarding and adjustments, help providing high-quality work experience, and support to make recruitment and workplaces more inclusive. Our work experience programmes and our delivery of the Connect to Work programme tell us that employers welcome this support.
We must also recognise the difference between an opportunity existing and a young person genuinely being able to access it. Transport, cost, health, caring responsibilities, location, and support needs can all determine whether a job, apprenticeship, course, or work placement is realistically within reach. In our research into the experiences of NEET young people in the North East of England, transport emerged repeatedly in discussions. Cost, travel time, shift patterns, and caring responsibilities all influenced whether opportunities felt realistic, with some limiting their job search to highly localised areas as a result.
Prevention that begins early and participation that lasts
The Milburn Review makes a strong case for investing before disengagement becomes entrenched, rather than continuing to pay for its consequences. It also rejects crude benefit cuts as a solution, arguing instead for greater investment in opportunities to learn or earn, and the practical support young people need to take them up.
For EDT, this focus on prevention is crucial. For example, we have seen through our Inspiring Careers Programme that careers guidance can be a preventative intervention. It is particularly effective when it begins early – the programme’s Careers Carousel days are offered to year groups as young as Year 7 – and continues through key transitions, rather than being concentrated in a single appointment. Our engagement with the KS3 Alliance, particularly its fourth pillar of ‘Skills, agency & pathways’, has also told us that earlier engagement with young people in schools is necessary for them to be able to make ambitious, informed choices about their futures. This principle of prevention needs to run through the entire system, from health to employers and local services.
“There is much to welcome in the Milburn Review, particularly its recognition that young people need both opportunity and sustained support, and that this support must begin much earlier. These recommendations align closely with EDT’s experience and research findings.
If these reforms are to make a lasting difference, we must ensure that all parts of the system work together to provide the sustained, wraparound support that each young person needs to succeed. Along with the rest of the EDT team, I am looking forward to working with the Government to implement Milburn’s recommendations, utilising EDT’s long experience working with young people in the UK.”

– Sarah Farquhar, CEO, EDT
The ultimate measure of these reforms should not simply be whether a young person enters work, education, or training. Confidence, readiness, engagement, and the quality of the opportunity all matter. The Review warns of the “lost life chances” that result when young people become disengaged. For EDT, with a purpose centred on improving life chances through education and employment, that goes to the heart of why prevention matters. The Milburn Review is an opportunity to move from reaction to prevention, creating genuine routes into work, and staying alongside young people for long enough to help them succeed.