Research 07/08/2022

England's approach to school performance data - lessons learned

By Martin Kaliszewski, Astrid Fieldsend, Tony McAleavy

Download now

This report distils down what others can learn from three decades of England’s approach to school performance data.

It highlights some of the lessons learned and the successes of the England national pupil data story; by sharing England’s story we hope that policymakers in other countries where a national pupil-level data system is being developed or refined may be able to avoid some of the mistakes and unexpected consequences that England encountered.

Data has played an important role in England’s recent school improvement journey. The National Pupil Database is a vital tool for health-checking the education system, driving accountability, directing education policymaking and tracking the educational attainment of key vulnerable groups. But getting to this data-rich point has not been without its challenges and documenting the journey provides useful lessons for others.

Our report provides analysis of and commentary on seven key accepted lessons:

Lesson 1: The school accountability system in England benefits from a data infrastructure of national tests and information about pupil characteristics, supported by technology
Lesson 2: English experience demonstrates the risks of an over-simplistic approach to school performance data
Lesson 3: In England there has been an important and lively debate about ‘value-added’ measures which take into account the starting points of pupils
Lesson 4: There is a need for a national accountability system that evolves over time
Lesson 5: Accountability measures used in England have played a significant role in the development of school self-evaluation
Lesson 6: Schools can benefit from comparing their own students’ performance with that of the national database through item-level analysis
Lesson 7: There should be an alignment between data-based support for internal school improvement and external school improvement through inspection

Downloads

England's approach to school performance data - lessons learned

This report distils down what others can learn from three decades of England’s approach to school performance data.

Download now

England's Approach To School Performance Data Lessons Learned Cover 180X255

Related Content

Article

EDT to support school improvement in Leicestershire through new local authority partnership

EDT is delighted to be working with Leicestershire Local Authority and 29 local schools through the Schools Partnership Programme (SPP), forming a supportive professional learning network (PLN) focused on sustainable school improvement. Working closely with school leadership teams and the Education Effectiveness Team (EET), which supports all education settings in Leicestershire, this partnership focuses on empowering all staff to actively participate in the school improvement process.

Research

Joint practice development through a peer-led school improvement partnership: research-driven recommendations for policymakers and school leaders

This report presents a summary of a three-year project conducted by academics at the University College London (UCL) Centre for Education Leadership, funded by the Education Endowment Foundation (EEF), evaluating EDT’s Schools Partnership Programme (SPP). On the SPP, clusters of schools conduct peer reviews and support one another’s improvement – leading to improved system leadership and greater accountability in England’s schools.

Research

Joint practice development through a peer-led school improvement partnership: research-driven recommendations for policymakers and school leaders

CLT And Curriculum Reform Insight Listing

Insights

Using cognitive load theory as a touchstone for curriculum reform: recommendations for policymakers

Cognitive load theory can inform curriculum design and classroom practices, offering concrete strategies to improve student outcomes. Dr Richard Churches, our Director of Research and author of the book Neuroscience for Teachers, and Dr David Johnson of the University of Oxford, discuss the potential of using CLT as part of curriculum design.