Research 01/08/2023

Assessing the potential to teach: predicting later classroom practice from assessment centre activities – conclusions from a four-year study

Download now

Teacher professional development is complex, and to date, there has been little research about how abilities prior to initial teacher training (ITT) influence early classroom practice. In this report, we draw on our experience of our Future Teaching Scholars programme in England to address this gap. Our analysis summarises a four-year study looking at the ability of assessment centres to predict teacher training candidates’ success in their later teaching practice.

Recruiting and retaining excellent teachers remains a pressing policy issue in education systems worldwide. According to UNESCO estimates, 68.8 million teachers will need to be recruited globally to meet Sustainable Development Goal 4. The situation in England is no exception: many schools face teacher recruitment and retention challenges, and the overall number of teachers qualified to teach in state schools has not kept pace with the increase in pupil numbers. Teacher vacancy rates have also increased as workload pressures intensify. Meeting this challenge will require not only the recruitment of high-quality teachers, but also the retention of such teachers within the education system.

As part of the recruitment and selection process for the Department of Education’s Future Teaching Scholars (FTS) programme, which seeks to recruit high-quality maths and physics teachers in England, we designed and implemented an education assessment centre. This is a common tool in recruitment in the UK, but a systematic review has shown that, despite the increase in their use in education, no robust studies of their long-term effectiveness exist.

The FTS assessment centre involved a competency-based interview, a reflective activity and a group problem-solving exercise. In addition, it used classroom roleplays, assessed by two practitioners – one of whom was a serving subject-specific teacher from an outstanding Teaching School – which sought to measure a candidate’s innate ‘mental set’ prior to teaching.

This report is the culmination of a four-year study looking at the ability of the FTS assessment centre to predict candidates’ success in their later practice as teachers. Building on previous reports, we present our final conclusions about the approach’s predictive validity and the standards of teaching achieved by participants at the end of their first term of teaching. We believe that the evidence from this evaluation could help policymakers, schools, and governments to select teachers more effectively.

To find out more about our Future Teaching Scholars Programme, please click here.

Downloads

Assessing the potential to teach

Teacher professional development is complex. Despite evidence from randomised controlled trials about key factors influencing this process, and evidence about teacher professional growth, there is little research about how abilities prior to initial teacher training influence early classroom practice.

Download now

Assessing The Potential To Teach 160X200

Related Content

Programme

Future Teaching Scholars

A teacher training programme nurturing a new generation of maths and physics teachers - from their undergraduate degree through to their ECT years.

Research

How to assess potential to teach: Data Insights report provides new evidence

Over the past two years, we have conducted the first two stages of a research project looking at the effectiveness of an education assessment centre and its ability to predict teacher effectiveness. Following our first report published in 2020, we have now published an update report for 2021, which accounts for the additional data we have gathered on our Future Teaching Scholars’ later classroom performance.

Insights

Future Teaching Scholars

On behalf of the Department for Education in England, Education Development Trust is delivering the Future Teaching Scholars programme, a new route into teaching for passionate maths and physics students to create a new generation of confident and highly skilled teachers.

Insights

Improving school attendance by fostering a sense of community belonging

Since 2010, school absence rates in England have gradually increased, and were undoubtedly exacerbated by the Covid-19 pandemic. Despite a small decrease in persistent absences from 2022 to 2023, attendance rates have not yet returned to pre-pandemic levels. In this article, we explore the causes of persistent school absences, and identify promising interventions to ensure more pupils in England consistently attend school.